Derek Jeter's playoffs heroics and Cole Hamels pitching woes

After watching the first round of the MLB playoffs I was incredibly irritated. Not only did the umpires get every other call wrong, but the players made way too many mental mistakes. There were many baserunning mistakes including Colby Rasmus trying to take third, Molina getting thrown out trying to take third on a groundball to short, and Nick Punto getting thrown out because he took to big of a turn at third base. I've been trying to figure out why so many "professional" baseball players seem to making terrible baserunning mistakes that little leaguers know not make. I figured out my answer when looking at Derek Jeter's flip against the A's in 2001. Yes the play was amazing, it was a perfect flip to Posada but there is one major problem with it; Jeter was completely out of position. On that play Jeter is supposed to be covering second base so that if Terrance Long tries to take third base and goes to far he will be caught in a rundown. But, like many plays these days Jeter moves completely out of position to field the overthrow and flip it to Posada. Yes the play worked but this is not a smart baseball play. This play shows perfectly why baseball players make so many silly mistakes. The players want to make the highlight reel, they want to be the star and make the game winning play. However, baseball is won by smart baseball not bad/lucky baseball which is what the Jeter play was.

This is not to take anything away from the fact that Jeter made an amazing, perfect flip to Posada, but if he is 1/2 a second slower or it is an inch farther from Posada then it will not be looked at as a sensational play. Everyone would have been talking about how Jeter was out of position